I would like to bring a technical issue to the table here

Started by munkyfistfight, December 21, 2006, 06:29:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

munkyfistfight

Ok, I screwed up a little here (no pun intended). I wasn't anticipating how tight this particular bolt was going to be, and I started to strip out the head when I did it by hand, then I went and bought an impact driver (which I needed anyways) but since the head was already kind of stripped out and it's in such a tight place, the driver did nothing. So then I went and bought some screw-out bits for my drill and they really did the most damage. I'd rather be spending my money on parts instead of tools at this point and now I think I'm going to have to save this part till last when I can take it to a shop and have them extract it.


Does anyone have any solutions to possibly getting it out before I take it to a shop? I was going to try to get some liquid wrench and a "bolt-out" bit for my drill. Has anyone had any problems in this little nook of the bike before? This is the bolt that holds the clutch release mechanism in place (but I'm sure you guys knew that)
Those who play by the book will always be beaten by those who write their own. -Travis Pastrana

h2olawyer

PB Blaster is better than Liquid Wrench.  I was a big fan of Liquid Wrench until Lucky mentioned PB.  That stuff is great.  If you can find it, Aero-Kroil is good too but nearly impossible to find.  PB is available at most auto parts & hardware stores.

As buggered up as that screw head is, you're pretty much limited to an extractor.  Too confined to get anything in to cut a straight slot in the head. Try soaking for  while with PB & use a left hand drill bit (if you can find one - try a machinist's supply shop).  The combination of PB, heat & vibration of the counterclockwise drilling may just loosen it up.

Others may have good ideas as well.

H2O
If you have an accident on a motorcycle, it's always your fault. Tough call, but it has to be that way. You're in the right, and dead -on a bike. The principle is not to have any accident. If you're involved in an an accident, it's because you did not anticipate. Then, by default, you failed.

Night Vision

Quote from: h2olawyer on December 21, 2006, 06:43:09 PM

Try soaking for  while with PB & use a left hand drill bit (if you can find one - try a machinist's supply shop).  The combination of PB, heat & vibration of the counterclockwise drilling may just loosen it up.
Others may have good ideas as well.


all good ideas (heat from a propane torch)
I found LH bits at Sears (of all places).

drill normally into the culprit with a generous sized bit... not too big that there won't be anything to grab... (or else you'll really be screwed) and try an easyout or LH drill bit after lots of PBB and some heat and just plain old whacking it to set up some vibration for the blaster to work/set in
if it ain't worth doing it the hard way....
it ain't worth doing it at all - Man Law
;D


if it ain't broke..... take it apart and find out why


don't give up.... don't ever give up - Jimmy Valvano

EH

heat the aluminum area around it before applying spray oil. the oil will get sucked in the threaded area by capillary action where it can do some work. not red hot, just hot. then drill a proper, deep enough, hole for the extractor. you can also use a punch and hammer to tap it counterclockwise. try these methods after heat and oil.

Brian Moffet

Before applying any type of flame or high heat, Clean Off That Grease!  You do not want anything flammable there when you apply a flame or high heat.

Brian

QBS

Since the screw is in such a confined area consider using a really sharp chisel with as narrow a cutting edge angle as possible to make a slot across the screw head.  Then use your new impact driver with a thin flat blade bit in it to break the screw loose.  Of course,  soak the area in PB Blaster first.  The idea of heating the area before applying the Blaster sounds good.

When you hit the impact driver with your first blow, make it a really good one.  Really give it your best shot.  Do whatever you can to make the blow as dead on straight and with as much swing freedom as you can.  The hammer of choice would be a 3 lb. hand sledge.   Hold the impact driver preloaded in the counter clockwise direction when you strike it.

If your first blow doesn't do the job, the head of the screw will probably be so trashed that your only other options will be to either use some type of screw extraction system or use a drill to completely remove the head of the screw.

FYI:  In the future, where possible, always use an impact driver to break screws loose first.  Then use a screw driver or the impact driver itself to complete the removal by hand.

Also, use an impact driver for the final twist during reassembly.  BUT, no more than two blows for steel threads and one blow for aluminum threads.  The best procedure is to get the screw fairly tight by hand using the impact drive as a hand held screw driver, then give it one, or two at the most, hammer blows.  Be careful and thoughtful, impact drivers are very powerful tools and will easily strip out threads, especially aluminum ones.  Steel threads are a little more forgiving.  Even so, don't take them for granted.

munkyfistfight

Thanks guys!  :D I'm going to spend this weekend cleaning as much of that cruddy grease out of there. It's been like that since I got the bike 4 years ago. That'll involve me moving the bike out of the bedroom and on to the porch.  >:( I was thinking for the heat I could use one of those benzo-torches from walmart. I don't think I'll need anything heavy duty.

How exactly does the PB work? Is it like a lubricant or does it loosen the grip on the bolt? I'm curious too how I should go about "soaking" the bolt in this stuff. I think I'll dig out the chisel and try to get my impact driver in there before I do any drilling. I guess I should make a christmas list of some tools I should definitely own  :P
Those who play by the book will always be beaten by those who write their own. -Travis Pastrana

h2olawyer

PB Blaster is an aerosol like WD-40 but has something in it that eats the rust.  they say it uses capillary action to get into the threads.  However it does it, it works great.

Frozen fasteners are a pain in the @$$!

H2O
If you have an accident on a motorcycle, it's always your fault. Tough call, but it has to be that way. You're in the right, and dead -on a bike. The principle is not to have any accident. If you're involved in an an accident, it's because you did not anticipate. Then, by default, you failed.

Lucky

Super handy tool:
get a Deremil (or black-n-decker) tool with cut-off wheels. you can cut a slot in a bolt & use the impact driver method below.

I have to take exception with QBS's suggestion of using an impact driver to tighten bolts.  the hardest bolts to remove are those that have been overtightened! in the automotive industry, we say they were installed by gorillas....  installing bolts into an aluminum threaded case with unkown force is asking begging for trouble!!

to properly fasten inportaint bolts like head bolts they should be tightened in 3 stages using a torque wrench, in a criss-cross pattern. most bolts on the bike will only be tightened to inch pounds.  the amount of the first 2 stages may seem rediculusly light, but it's the proper way to do it.

to properly loosen bolts, use a 6 point socket (not 12 point) and a long breaker bar to 'crack' the bolts free.  the longer the bar the better (more leverage.)  loosen screws, with an impact driver set to 'reverse'

I would suggest soaking every visible bolt in PBlaster for at least a day if not longer. (soak a rag in pblaster & keep it over the bolt. pblaster does dry out, but be careful, it is flamable!!! (don't smoke or use a torch anywhere near the rags!)

I've never said this before, but that bike is a real basket case... i'm not sure it's even worth fixing, or even for parts..  i hope my saying that makes you want to prove me wrong, & that you do, but sometimes you have to weigh 'worth'....  if you do decide to restore it, you have my full support, but visions in much better shape have been parted out (more good parts for you though!)

which ever way you go, best of luck!!

--Lucky
1982/3 XZ550 Touring Vison, Gold on Black

Lucky

and my apologies to QBS, for whom i have the utmost respect, but we've had a lot of alternate points of view lately... i've NEVER IN MY LIFE stripped threads out of anything...
1982/3 XZ550 Touring Vison, Gold on Black

QBS

Lucky:  My entire post was specificaly addressed to the use of impact drivers to facilitate the removal and installation of SCREWS....not bolts. 

Lucky

i wouldn't use an impact driver to install screws either.  if there are no torque specks given for a fastener (other than standard specs for fastener size) such as screws, than 'hand tight' is all that is required. if further security is needed due to vibration or heating/cooling cycles, then a split, star or lock washer should be used.

smaller shaft screws are even more of a pain to get out...
1982/3 XZ550 Touring Vison, Gold on Black

QBS

Interesting.  You completely misinterpeted my post, didn't acknowledge your error, and then critically carried on without further thought.  And you're right, we have had  "a lot of alternate points of view lately".

YellowJacket!

I got a tool kit at Advanced autoparts for just that thing.  It looks like  a socket wrench set but it has reversed teeth in the socket that are razer sharp (um, dont ask how I know but for those of you that know me, its a s sharp  as the bagle slicer).  You use it just like you would a socket wrench and i bithes into the screw or bolt head and pulls it right out.  Thats how I was able to get the soft screws out of my carbs.  Its made bu a company called "Irwin" and comes in two different sized sets.  I payed about 20.00 for mine and it was WELL worth it.  Works even better with PB Blaster.

David


Living the dream - I am now a Physician Assistant!!   :-)

h2olawyer

#14
Forgot all about those - Sears sells them, too.  They work great & no drilling!

H2O
If you have an accident on a motorcycle, it's always your fault. Tough call, but it has to be that way. You're in the right, and dead -on a bike. The principle is not to have any accident. If you're involved in an an accident, it's because you did not anticipate. Then, by default, you failed.

kiawrench

i must be lazy, bolts are popped with pbb and a 36 in breaker bar, screws ith pb and a working screw driver. it if strips, i drill it out, tap it next size up and then drop a lil bit of anti sieze on it ,so i dont face that same screw again .    the sears set is good, ,the set fro m advance is too,  the snap on set is useless,,, they dont seem to bite well into anything  traded mine from snap on for a zytel bodied die grinder - doesnt get cold when in use like old steel bodied ones .
keep your bike running,your beer cold ,and your passport handy.all are like money in the bank .

supervision

  I would lay the bike on it's side, strike the head with a sharp chisel...  then use a impact driver.   The shock of the chisel, followed by the shock of impact should do the trick.   I've been putting never-sieze on the threads of everything for awhile now, you'll thank youself the next time you take it apart.  Make sure the driver is set for loosening, and give it a slight preload counterclockwise, then one good blow with two pound hammer.
" border="0

munkyfistfight

True, my bike has seen better days, but as far as I can see, it's mechanically sound. I definitely don't want something that looks nice or that I will regret damaging. All in all, this is just a fun project for me, and if it costs some to get it running than so be it.
Thanks for being honest, but I'm going to take my chances getting her running. I've done work on cars before and thought I'd try sinking my teeth into something a bit more delicate.

The clutch release mechanism was broken where the cable connects when I got it. I pulled the case sides and valve covers to see if there was anything wrong on the inside and everything turns nicely. One camshaft was welded to the sprocket for reasons unknown but nothing else seems wrong. The stator seems to be burnt, but I'm going to post a picture to see what you guys think. The fuel tank was destroyed and the instrument cluster and seat were damaged from being exposed to the elements. The pipes were a bit rusty as well. :-P

Other than that, the bike just needs some love. I have it stripped down to the bare minimum so I can work on it, and I'm learning alot about the nuances of mechanics which to me are invaluable.

I know I ask alot of questions and I really appreciate everyones help. Thankyou for all of the helpful tips and if I happen to meet you guys on the road someday, the first round is on me.

-Nate

Those who play by the book will always be beaten by those who write their own. -Travis Pastrana

Tiger

 :) I'm ripping down a motor for spare's...let me know if you need anything... ;) This "Family" will help you get her running...one way or another  ;D :D... ;)

                    8).......TIGER....... 8)
Life should NOT be a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving safely in an attractive and well-preserved body, but rather to skid in sideways, body thoroughly used up, totally worn out and screaming HOOOOYA lets go again baby !!!!!!

'82 Vision, Pearl Orange finish, lots of up-grades!!!

munkyfistfight

For the motor, if you've got a decent stator and a clutch-release rod, let me know :-p There's a shiny penny in it for ya  :D
Those who play by the book will always be beaten by those who write their own. -Travis Pastrana